Site not look beautiful? Click here

CineVegas 2009

Asylum Seekers

A movie brimming with ideas but little storytelling discipline and even less human emotion, Asylum Seekers begins with a promising premise: Six social misfits seek to opt out of society by competing against each other for one spot in an asylum. They include a girl addicted to computers; a right-wing government conspiracy nut; a woman locked in a loveless marriage; a deranged virgin; an egomaniacal rapper; and an exhibitionist who’s paranoid that everyone’s looking at her.

CineVegas 2009

Asylum Seekers
Two stars
Pepper Binkley, Bill Dawes, Judith Hawkings, Daniel Irizarry.
Directed by Rania Ajami.
Asylum Seekers
More CineVegas
Complete coverage of CineVegas 2009
Film reviews

But the movie plods along with the lumpy uncertainty of a first draft, playing out as a series of workshop-like vignettes that build to nothing. At one point the characters are made to participate in that universal symbol of creative lethargy, a (grating) talent show.

The movie’s surreal atmosphere of psychological suspense is undercut by its comedy, which itself is fairly limp, and director Ajami cannot seem to corral her ambitious ideas about the nature of “normalcy” into a dramatically satisfying form.

Worse, for the most part the characters are only types—and the actors play them too broadly to give us anything to grab onto. Too bad, because Ajami shows some skill in the few scenes where she lets the hidden yearnings of her characters come out. But these moments quickly fade, and we’re left instead with increasingly overwrought symbolism, a film that circles around itself but never finds it way.


Commenting Policy

Previous Discussion:

  • Despite the drastic changes in TV-viewing habits in recent years, the major broadcast networks insist on rolling out dozens of new shows in early fall.

  • From Johnny Depp in a gritty biopic to the retro-fueled insanity of Canadian filmmaker Guy Maddin, fall films are ready to thrill.

  • Diary is based on Phoebe Gloeckner’s semi-autobiographical graphic novel and set in San Francisco in 1976.

  • Get More Film Stories
Top of Story