Film

The Book Thief’ fails to capture its source material

Image
From let, Sophie Nélisse, Emily Watson and Geoffrey Rush star in The Book Thief.

Two and a half stars

The Book Thief Sophie Nélisse, Emily Watson, Geoffrey Rush. Directed by Brian Percival. Rated PG-13. Now playing.

The Book Thief feels very much as if it stole a book itself: the best-selling 2005 source novel, written by Australian author Markus Zusak. Like many literary adaptations, this one skims hurriedly over the surface of a sprawling narrative, attempting to make up for the lack of complexity or nuance by serving up grandiose emotional cues. The adventures of Liesel (Sophie Nélisse), a 9-year-old girl who’s deposited with a married couple (Emily Watson and Geoffrey Rush) when her Communist mother flees the Nazis, involve war, death (Death actually narrates the story, in fact), illiteracy, a semi-wicked stepmother (okay, foster mother) and the sheltering of a Jewish refugee (Ben Schnetzer); while a 550-page novel has room to deftly juggle so many harrowing elements, a two-hour movie simply does not.

Director Brian Percival, who’s previously worked mostly in British television, treats each strand of the plot as if it were an item on a checklist, relying heavily on one of John Williams’ most overbearing, saccharine scores to goose the viewer into feeling something. For fans of the book, seeing a condensed dramatization might be a worthwhile supplement to a treasured experience, but anyone coming to the material cold will be left that way.

Share

Commenting Policy

  • It's an enjoyable but slightly scuzzy movie for an actor who’s free to make them.

  • Everything in theaters this week, plus special screenings and movie reviews.

  • Pixar gets all the attention but Laika has built up a body of work nearly as impressive with a creative voice that’s just as distinctive.

  • Get More Film Stories
Top of Story