Site not look beautiful? Click here


Film review: ‘Earth to Echo’ little more than a low-budget ‘E.T.’ ripoff

Instead of taking your kids to see Earth to Echo, rent The Goonies or Flight of the Navigator. You’ll have a lot more fun.

Two and a half stars

Earth to Echo Teo Halm, Brian “Astro” Bradley, Reese C. Hartwig. Directed by Dave Green. Rated PG. Now playing.

Like J.J. Abrams’ Super 8, Earth to Echo owes a lot to ’80s kids-adventure movies like E.T., The Goonies and Flight of the Navigator, but director Dave Green doesn’t come close to replicating the emotional depth or sense of wonder that Abrams was able to capture. Instead, Earth to Echo is a low-rent imitation, shot in a found-footage style that mostly makes it look cheap and slapdash, with half-hearted character arcs and very little suspense.

The three preteen friends (played by Teo Halm, Brian “Astro” Bradley and Reese C. Hartwig) who rescue an injured alien are likable but one-dimensional, and the performances by the young actors are pretty broad. The alien itself, which looks like a little robotic owl, is cute enough for a merchandising bonanza, but its story of trying to find its way home is a blatant E.T. rip-off. Kids may not realize how blandly derivative Earth to Echo is, but their parents, at least, should know better.


Commenting Policy

  • The film features Sylvester Stallone’s best performance in a long time.

  • Not surprisingly for Pixar, the animation is gorgeous to look at, and it’s solid, pleasurable entertainment for kids.

  • Eilis is a good person who deserves a good life, and even through her occasional inner turmoil, she’s able to achieve it.

  • Get More Film Stories
Top of Story