Site not look beautiful? Click here

As We See It

With bottle fraud in the news, we ask a sommelier what’s what


Billionaires have it rough. Per New York magazine last week: “Energy magnate William Koch is suing Internet tycoon Eric Greenberg for selling him $300,000 worth of vintage ‘as-is’ bottles of wine that he claims are fakes.”

Rich or poor, we all want to get what we pay for—and we all should be wary when buying old wine. John Paddon, wine director for Caesars Palace, says counterfeiting really took off with the popularity and scarcity of 1961 and 1982 vintages of Bordeaux. When $50 bottles become $5,000 bottles, opportunists start refilling.

Among Paddon’s many buying tips:

1. “Always deal with the most scrupulous people that you can find.”

2. Buy in cases to check label uniformity.

3. Cork is a tell-tale sign.

4. If you can afford amazing wine, maybe you can afford a sommelier to verify its quality.

If you’re buying pre-1900, that’s serious. “For those types of authentications, you’re talking about so much money that there’s a chemical-composition test,” Paddon says. Not only does it carbon date wine, it tells you (within about 20 miles) where it came from.

Paddon says there’s only so much we can do to protect ourselves. Plus, most of us don’t know the difference between a decent fake and a real treasure. “I can teach anybody the difference between good and bad in about 20 minutes,” Paddon says. “But the difference between good and great? That kinda takes a lifetime.”

Tags: Dining, News
Photo of Erin Ryan

Erin Ryan

Erin got her first newspaper job in 2002 thanks to a campfire story about Bigfoot. In her award-winning work for ...

Get more Erin Ryan

Commenting Policy

Previous Discussion:

  • Spinning natural ingredients into beauty treatments used to be Heather Marianna's hobby. Now it's her business.

  • A training on transgender cultural competence, the event was held in memory of an Ohio teen who committed suicide due to a lack of understanding ...

  • The annual porn convention returned this year with more space to explore and an expanded seminar series for fans.

  • Get More As We See It Stories
Top of Story