A&E

[5-MINUTE EXPERT]

Sound gardens: Which music streaming service is best for you?

Image
Shutterstock

Swedish music streaming service Spotify launched in the United States in July 2011. Before that, the amount of music you could carry with you was limited to the memory of your iPod—and, coincidentally, to you remembering to take your iPod out of your gym clothes before dropping them in the wash. Spotify, with its millions of songs (50 million, at last count), completely changed all that. It not only negated consumer need to purchase music players like iPods, but the need to purchase music itself. Seconds after signing up, Spotify spills an avalanche of songs into your lap. Just as soon as you learn of the existence of a new Haim record, you can listen to it—without commercials even, if you pay a monthly fee.

The long-term impact of services like Spotify on the business of recorded music is still unfolding. (There’s an ongoing question of artist compensation, for one thing, but we won’t go into all that now, except to say that all artists deserve to earn at least a living wage from their work.) And from a consumer standpoint, these streaming services aren’t yet perfect. They compress audio files, skimp on liner notes and album art, and, in some cases—due to licensing issues, label disputes or the reticence of individual artists—omit songs, albums or entire label catalogs.

Still, we’re very close to a sonic utopia. How can a music fan hope to build a complete sound library in the cloud, one that not only includes otherwise omitted tracks but also favorite bootlegs and rarities? Amazingly, certain streaming services are taking steps to help realize that crazy dream. Here’s the current breakdown.

AMAZON MUSIC UNLIMITED

Cost? $9.99/month; $7.99/month or $79.99/year for Amazon Prime members

How many songs? 60 million

Can you upload music you own? No. But music purchased through Amazon is added to your library, so if Prince’s estate has second thoughts, you can just buy Sign ‘O’ the Times and get the MP3s back that way. Yeah, it’s not ideal.

Why bother? When you factor in the Amazon Prime member discount, it’s the cheapest service out there. And hi-def streaming is available at $12.99/month for Prime members or $14.99/month—a big savings over HD champ Tidal.

APPLE MUSIC

Cost? $9.99/month; $99/year

How many songs? 60 million

Can you upload music you own? Yes, up to 100,000 songs.

Why bother? Service-only exclusive albums and tracks. Beats 1 radio and iHeart Radio streaming channels. And if you’re deep into Apple’s walled garden, you’re probably already a subscriber.

IBROADCAST

Cost? Free

How many songs? Nothing but what you bring to it.

Can you upload music you own? Yes. That’s the whole point of iBroadcast; it’s a streaming music locker that’s just for music you personally own.

Why bother? Again, it’s free. (A premium version, with adjustable stream quality, is in the works, but iBroadcast says the core service will remain free.) And if you have qualms about supporting multibillionaires, this Seattle-based upstart is the way to go.

SPOTIFY

Cost? $9.99/month; $99/year

How many songs?“Over 50 million.” Probably closer to 60, like everyone else.

Can you upload music you own? No. But you can use Spotify to listen to audio files stored locally on your device.

Why bother? With its easy-to-use interface and surprisingly intuitive artist recommendation algorithms, it remains the gold standard. There’s a good reason practically every new phone or smart device comes with Spotify baked in.

TIDAL

Cost? $9.99/month for standard audio, $19.99 for hi-def audio

How many songs? 60 million, with more than 250,00 music videos.

Can you upload music you own? No.

Why bother? Lossless audio. Tidal’s standard audio songs stream at 320 kbps—the same as Spotify, Apple and most everyone else—but its acclaimed hi-def option offers master-quality recording streams, a must for devoted audiophiles.

Share
Photo of Geoff Carter

Geoff Carter

Experts in paleoanthropology believe that Geoff Carter began his career in journalism sometime in the early Grunge period, when he ...

Get more Geoff Carter
  • The Tony Award-winning musical “Follies” will take the stage at Access Showroom at Aliante Casino & Hotel for six performances starting on April 11.

  • Since opening at the Linq Promenade in March 2014, Brooklyn Bowl Las Vegas has been a destination for some of the best and most under-appreciated ...

  • Sagittarius, for your own selfish sake, you need to pour out more adoration and care and compassion than you ever have before.

  • Get More A&E Stories
Top of Story