Jack the Giant Slayer’ is another mediocre retelling

Beanstalker: Hoult’s Jack climbs toward adventure.

The Details

Jack the Giant Slayer
Two and a half stars
Nicholas Hoult, Eleanor Tomlinson, Ewan McGregor
Directed by Brian Singer
Rated PG-13, opens Friday
Beyond the Weekly
Official Movie Site
IMDb: Jack the Giant Slayer
Rotten Tomatoes: Jack the Giant Slayer

Here we go again: Jack the Giant Slayer is the latest example of Hollywood’s mania for reimagined fairy tales, following in the dubious footsteps of Red Riding Hood, Mirror Mirror, Snow White and the Huntsman, Hansel and Gretel: Witch Hunters and even the TV series Once Upon a Time. Jack has a decent pedigree, with director Bryan Singer (the first two X-Men movies, The Usual Suspects) behind the camera, but it still comes out as an utterly generic Hollywood product, easily envisioned by plugging “Jack and the beanstalk” and “action blockbuster” into a theoretical screenplay generator (although the movie has four credited screenwriters).

Nicholas Hoult plays the title character, a humble farm boy sent to town to sell his family’s horse and carriage. There he acquires the expected magic beans, which here have been invested with a cursory backstory involving “dark magic” laid out in a Lord of the Rings-style prologue. The mechanics aren’t really relevant; the important thing is that the beans are planted, the giant beanstalk grows, and Jack finds himself climbing toward the kingdom of the giants, to rescue the requisite princess (Eleanor Tomlinson).

Hoult and Tomlinson play two-dimensional characters in a one-dimensional romance, and it’s hard to get invested in the predictable outcome of their pairing. The supporting characters have a little more flavor, but the pacing is off, meaning that Stanley Tucci gets to be delightfully villainous for about two-thirds of the movie (as a scheming lord set to marry the princess) before being completely discarded. Ian McShane (as the noble king), Ewan Bremner (as Tucci’s sniveling sidekick) and Ewan McGregor (as the head of the king’s guard) all have their moments, but in pretty limited fashion.

Aside from the spectacle of McGregor going into an oven as a human-in-a-blanket, there isn’t much humor, and the climactic battle seems like an afterthought added because the running time was too short and there weren’t enough explosions. With its paint-by-numbers plot and dull characters, Jack is like a Syfy miniseries with better special effects. Can we leave the fairy tales alone already?


Josh Bell

Josh Bell is the film editor for Las Vegas Weekly, where he's been writing movie and TV reviews since 2002. ...

Get more Josh Bell

Previous Discussion:

  • Shan Michael Evans presents playful, bold designs that could be at home in a hipster toy store. “[If] any of these works receive a smile ...

  • “People are expressing themselves in different ways that were hidden before and not talked about. It gives you a chance to say, ‘Here I am. ...

  • Between Starbucks and Border Grill, an oasis awaits. Twenty-four medium-format paintings by Kisho Mwkaiyama hang on the wall, their complex significance perhaps overlooked by conference ...

  • Get More Fine Art Stories
Top of Story