IN PRINT: A Grand Theory

Not quite unified, global look at soccer is still a solid read

John Freeman

During the run up to this year's World Cup, the Vietnamese government warned its soccer-mad population about the health concerns of viewing too many games. "Staying up overnight and working the next day could exhaust watchers, making them lose their appetite," worried the Vietnam News Agency.


One needn't tune into ESPN to realize that many folks around the world would gladly skip a meal to take in a game of soccer, and New Republic magazine journalist Franklin Foer happens to be one of them. In How Soccer Explains the World, Foer describes his travels far and wide to view his favorite sport—and what they told him about globalization.


Over the course of this fine book, Foer travels from Brazil to Belgrade, from Ukraine to Tehran and further yet. He enters each city and team with the sprit of a true fan, and emerges with impressions so vivid that they feel like he's belted them into your ear over a nice pint of lager.


How Soccer Explains the World begins with hooligan-style teams, featuring fan clubs that like to fight, and winds up in the squeaky clean American little league. The beginning of the book, then, contains some of the most memorable chapters, as Foer travels to Belgrade, Glasgow and Budapest, where fans unfurl gigantic banners mocking each other's ethnic and religious roots. "The trains are leaving for Auschwitz," one banner reads at a match in Hungary.


Although some of this rhetoric is indeed just that, what interests Foer is where it comes from. The Red Star fans in Belgrade borrowed their hooliganism from the English clubs, and then draped it with the aesthetic of American gangster rap. Now that yuppies have infiltrated the ranks of Chelsea supporters in England, the old guard makes appointments to scrap with opposing team's fans—away from the stadium.


While Foer focuses on amusing stories like that, there also is a sad side to globalization's failures. In one chapter, Foer tells of Edward Anyamkyegh, a Nigerian player brought to play in Ukraine for a price of $500,000. It sounds like a dream come true for Edward, until you consider how his teammates resented his paycheck. When Foer asks Edward's coach how he motivates Edward and another African player, the man's response is chilling. "I've told them ... you've got ability, boys. You've got ambition, I suppose. If you don't do well, if you're not disciplined, if you're not ambitious enough, and can't match my ambition, I'll send you back to Africa."


In its own haphazard way, Foer's reporting underscores what an uphill battle globalization advocates must fight. A global economy may bring African players to a new continent and for fairer wages, but it can't ensure their success or cultural adaptation. Similarly, globalization may bring foreign investors to a hopelessly corrupt Brazilian team, such as Vasco de Gama, but it cannot cure that club of thieving strongmen presidents.


To Foer's credit, How Soccer Explains the World never even tries to cobble these snapshots into a cohesive theory, though the book's subtitle promises otherwise. After all, the big problem with globalization as a theory is that it flattens out cultural differences; it makes assumptions that feel good in one time zone but can't be applied in another. With this superbly reported first book, Foer has gone one step better. He's gotten off his rump, humped his way around the world and brought back a kaleidoscopic view of a vibrant game and the people who believe in it. One might say it's a terrific example of the good things globalization can bring to your doorstep.

  • Get More Stories from Thu, Jul 29, 2004
Top of Story