Thumbs up or down for Roger Ebert?

Giving the blow-by-blow of the famous movie critic’s new show


Co-hosts Christy Lemire and Ignatiy Vishnevetsky: Lemire, of the Associated Press, and Vishnevetsky, of Mubi.com and the Chicago Reader, are a bit mismatched, and while they were more than willing to disagree on pretty much every movie, they also seemed to be talking past each other much of the time. They may eventually settle into a nice chemistry, but for now they get a thumbs down.

Werner Herzog as the voice of Roger Ebert: Because of cancer surgery, Ebert lost his ability to speak a few years ago, so his segment was narrated by director Werner Herzog, one of the greatest voices in cinema. I don’t know if they can keep this up each week, but it gets a big thumbs up.

Kim Morgan on classic cinema: Morgan (who writes for MSN and other outlets) is one of the best and most passionate writers about old Hollywood, and her segment on The Third Man was top-notch. I give it a thumbs up and hope to see more.

Overall: Even with a few bumps, it’s great to have a TV show devoted to real cinephilia back on the air. I miss A.O. Scott and Michael Phillips as At the Movies hosts, but I wouldn’t hesitate to give this new version my thumbs up.


Josh Bell

Josh Bell is the film editor for Las Vegas Weekly, where he's been writing movie and TV reviews since 2002. ...

Get more Josh Bell

Previous Discussion:

  • “I had my 30th birthday in Vegas, and I’m still trying to rehydrate now. … We went to a shooting range with a bunch of ...

  • He’s a 24-year-old millionaire, and like any young breadwinner, occasionally feels asphyxiated by the harsher facts of life. No wonder his music has caught on—these ...

  • Shan Michael Evans presents playful, bold designs that could be at home in a hipster toy store. “[If] any of these works receive a smile ...

  • Get More A&E Stories
Top of Story